Ancelotti’s Exit: 3 Bold Moves for Real Madrid’s Future Post-Arsenal Loss

Ancelotti’s exit from the Champions League spotlight, following Real Madrid’s crushing 5-1 aggregate defeat to Arsenal on April 16, 2025, has cast uncertainty over the Spanish giants’ future. The 2-1 loss at the Santiago Bernabéu, sealed by goals from Bukayo Saka and Gabriel Martinelli, ended Madrid’s reign as European champions and intensified scrutiny on manager Carlo Ancelotti. With his contract running until 2026, questions swirl about his tenure, the squad’s direction, and the club’s next steps. This blog explores the implications of this setback, potential replacements, and how Real Madrid can reclaim their dominance.

Table of Contents

1. Ancelotti’s Exit: The Champions League Fallout

2. Why Ancelotti’s Position Is Under Threat

3. Three Strategic Moves for Real Madrid’s Revival

4. Xabi Alonso: The Frontrunner to Replace Ancelotti

5. Squad Overhaul: Addressing Key Weaknesses

6. The Road Ahead: La Liga and Copa del Rey

7. Conclusion

Ancelotti’s Exit: The Champions League Fallout

Real Madrid’s elimination from the Champions League marked their first failure to reach the semi-finals since 2020. Arsenal’s dominance, particularly in the 3-0 first-leg win at the Emirates, exposed Madrid’s tactical and personnel shortcomings. Despite a late equalizer from Vinícius Júnior in the second leg, Madrid lacked cohesion, managing only one shot on target until the 55th minute. Ancelotti admitted Arsenal were “better than us,” citing a controversial overturned penalty as a missed opportunity to shift momentum.

The defeat has fueled speculation about Ancelotti’s future. “I don’t know,” he told Movistar Plus when asked if it was his last Champions League game with Madrid, adding that any decision rests with the club. Posts on X reflect fan frustration, with some calling the performance an “embarrassment” and urging a managerial change. Yet, Ancelotti’s storied record—five Champions League titles, three with Madrid—demands respect, complicating the narrative.

Why Ancelotti’s Position Is Under Threat

Ancelotti’s second stint at Madrid, starting in 2021, delivered a La Liga-Champions League double in 2024. However, the 2024-25 season has been marred by inconsistency, with 11 losses across all competitions, including two heavy defeats to Barcelona (4-0 in La Liga, 5-2 in the Spanish Super Cup). Injuries to key players like Dani Carvajal and David Alaba, coupled with the departures of Toni Kroos and Karim Benzema, have exposed squad depth issues.

Critics, including French journalist Julien Laurens on BBC Match of the Day, argue Ancelotti’s reliance on individual brilliance over tactical structure has faltered. “There was no plan tactically, it was an absolute mess,” Laurens said. The board’s failure to sign reinforcements, despite Ancelotti’s requests for players like Harry Kane, has compounded the problem. Reports from The Athletic suggest Brazil’s interest in Ancelotti for the 2026 World Cup, adding further uncertainty.

Three Strategic Moves for Real Madrid’s Revival

To rebound from this setback, Real Madrid must act decisively. Here are three bold moves to secure their future:

1. Appoint a New Manager: Ancelotti’s exit seems imminent, with Onda Cero reporting he may leave after the Club World Cup in June 2025. A fresh perspective could revitalize the squad.

2. Strengthen the Squad: The defense and midfield need urgent reinforcements. Signing a top center-back and a creative midfielder could address vulnerabilities exposed by Arsenal.

3. Embrace Youth: Promoting academy talents like Raúl Asencio or integrating young signings could inject energy, balancing the squad’s reliance on veterans like Luka Modrić.

These steps could restore Madrid’s competitive edge across competitions.

Xabi Alonso: The Frontrunner to Replace Ancelotti

Bayer Leverkusen’s Xabi Alonso, a former Madrid midfielder, is the leading candidate to succeed Ancelotti. Alonso’s success in leading Leverkusen to an unbeaten Bundesliga title in 2023-24 showcases his tactical acumen and modern approach. The Athletic reports that talks between Alonso’s representatives and Madrid have occurred, with his agency’s ties to the club strengthening his case.

Alonso’s familiarity with Madrid’s culture, having played 236 matches for the club, makes him a natural fit. His dynamic, high-pressing style could maximize stars like Kylian Mbappé and Jude Bellingham, addressing the “passivity” Ancelotti noted against Arsenal. However, prising Alonso from Leverkusen, where he’s contracted until 2026, may require a significant effort from president Florentino Pérez.

Squad Overhaul: Addressing Key Weaknesses

Madrid’s squad, despite boasting talents like Mbappé and Bellingham, lacks depth. The Athletic highlights Ancelotti’s frustration with limited bench options during the Arsenal tie, where substitutes like Lucas Vázquez and Brahim Díaz failed to spark a comeback. The midfield, depleted since Kroos’s retirement, struggles for control, while the defense has been hit hard by injuries to Alaba, Carvajal, and Éder Militão.

To compete with Europe’s elite, Madrid must invest in January. A center-back like Aymeric Laporte and a midfielder like Martín Zubimendi could provide stability. Offloading underperforming veterans and integrating youth prospects will also be key. For more on Madrid’s transfer strategy, visit ESPN’s analysis.

The Road Ahead: La Liga and Copa del Rey

Despite the Champions League exit, Madrid remain in contention for silverware. They trail Barcelona by four points in La Liga with eight games left, with a crucial Clásico looming. The Copa del Rey final against Barcelona offers another shot at a trophy, while the Club World Cup in June 2025 provides a global stage. Ancelotti emphasized staying focused on these competitions, urging his team to “hold our heads high and learn from our mistakes.”

A strong finish could secure Ancelotti’s position, but the pressure is on. Goalkeeper Thibaut Courtois defended his manager, insisting the players have “no problem” with him, but fan sentiment on X suggests a desire for change, with many eyeing Alonso as the future.

Conclusion

Ancelotti’s exit from the Champions League has thrust Real Madrid into a pivotal moment. The 5-1 loss to Arsenal exposed tactical and squad deficiencies, raising questions about the Italian’s future. With potential replacements like Xabi Alonso waiting and a need for squad investment, Madrid must act boldly to reclaim their status. As they chase La Liga and Copa del Rey glory, the coming months will define the club’s trajectory. Whether Ancelotti stays or goes, one thing is clear: Real Madrid’s next chapter demands transformation.

Read more

Read Also: Club Statement: Lachlan Galvin